Agile project management is one of the hottest topics in the project management professional field and technology industries.
It is planned that Agile will permeate many sections of the next edition of PMI’s Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK® Guide). The implications and potential impact of this are significant.
Is this a good idea? Are the interest in and applicability of Agile as widespread as it is made out to be?
A Devil’s Advocate
Playing devil’s advocate, I wonder if the PM professional world, academic researchers, organizations, and many in the field of project management are getting carried away with the “Agile” concept? Is it as widely applicable or used as implied in the many articles and papers on the topic?
How important is the move towards Agile, and how many organizations and industries does it apply to? Why are those who do not use Agile so silent on this topic?
A recent paper by Salum, Amaral, da Silva and Almeida, asks “Can agile project management be adopted by industries other than software development”.
While Agile concepts appear to be used almost exclusively for new product development, primarily for developing software-based products or systems, it also seems to be migrating to use for innovation in other industries.
How Applicable is Agile?
How applicable is it for projects where most products are procured? For example, how can Agile be applied to construction projects?
For any project involving physical facilities, products or systems, especially any with safety implications, it would seem that waterfall planning, design, and implementation models must be required.
For projects such as a massive refinery, transportation system, or hospital, iterative Agile methods would not seem practical or useful only in limited tasks. Also, for larger projects, documentation is essential. Both formality and documentation seem anathema to Agile.
Looking across sectors such as Construction, Government Expenditure, Health & Medical, Infrastructure, Mining & Petroleum, how many of these projects would apply Agile methods?
If these and other industries where traditional projects and waterfall-based project management represent such an enormous portion of the global economy, why is Agile commanding so much attention?
Yes, technology and software are critical to business and modern economies. And yes, technology companies spend a lot of money on projects.
But... perhaps more focus should be placed on organizations and leaders struggling with projects in the waterfall world. In my opinion, that is where the need is still greatest.”
If you wish to better your Agile fundamentals, taking the Certified Agile Project Management course will make you a great Agile leader and teach you techniques that help with implementing Agile principles and values into your team.
This blog is an edited version of "A Devil’s Advocate: Agile from a distance, the big waterfall world, Vol. VI, Issue IV–April 2017", by David Pells, Managing editor of PMWorldJournal.net.
About David Pells
President, PM World Inc., Managing Director, PM World Library Fellow, PMI; Fellow (Hon), APM, PMA, SOVNET.
David L. Pells is an internationally recognized leader in professional project management and acts in advisory roles for several global programs and organizations. His professional experience includes various programs and projects, including engineering, construction, defence, transit and high technology, and project sizes ranging from several thousand to ten billion dollars. He is a member of the Global Advisory Board for the Institute of Project Management. He served on the board of directors of the Project Management Institute (PMI®) twice and was awarded PMI’s Person of the Year award in 1998 and Fellow Award in 1999
Table of Contents
Get the latest news and insights in project management